They both look horrid! I just don't get the concept of either of them as a guest poser??? Big yes... am I impressed... hell no!
Neither of them are out of shape for an off-season. Kevin does have a lot of water retention but it's clear to me that his body fat is still in the single digits (I've pulled countless of body fats over the past 9 years as a personal trainer to grant me the credibility to have an accurate assessment of that by eye). He still has visible abs, quad separation and semi-striated pecs. Those are not indications of an out of shape off-season.