2010 Arnold's comparison pics are the closest in terms of scaling and stuff, and Phil was actually a bit better at the O this year compared to the Arnold where he still won the prejudging, so Phil @ Mr O 2010 overall is better than his earlier appearance and wins in this comparison too.
Adbominal-thigh belongs to Kai. Phil no doubt has the best aesthetics out of anyone in the Cutler era, but he and Kai are damn close. It is not fair to say no contest since we all know bodybuilding judges don't care all that much for what actually looks good, but rather what looks revolting. Dorian and Jay both have the aesthetics of a brick wall. Kai and Oscar may have ****ed the Olympia this year, but don't rule Kai out. A sad Kai is a determined Kai, and I have a feeling Kai is sadder than ever!