Guys, I see this issue this way:
1) Ronnie (AGAIN) is the best BB ever. Therefore, at their primes, he is better than Jay Cutler. Period.
2) (And this is no debatable) Jay won more pro contests than anyone in this past decade (2002-2011). In fact, he never came worse than 2nd.
So, Jay being the bodybuilder of these past 10 years doesn't seem a lie to me.