Was Tonight's Judging Fair?

lifterdead · Sep 28, 2008

Well?

Was it or was it not?

:dunnodude:

Deathmaggot · Sep 28, 2008

it didnt even ended dude

Flex · Sep 28, 2008

Meh. Some good calls, some bad.

lifterdead · Sep 28, 2008

LOL, I totally thought they'd give it to JAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

h0ke · Sep 28, 2008

Meh. Some good calls, some bad.
Phil and Wolf looked better than Cutler IMO.
Dexter deserved to be the winner.

theweapon · Sep 28, 2008

phil should have been after dex honestly

Pickle · Sep 28, 2008

agreed with the above. some good some bad bad being jay inside top 3

Flex · Sep 28, 2008

Any judging that puts Freeman out of the top 4 is not good judging.

DriDDeRz · Sep 28, 2008

some good call outs
some bad ones
and a great new champion!

Line · Sep 28, 2008

It was fair enough. Certainly a step in the right direction.

MuscleMecca Crew

Rageking · Sep 28, 2008

Line said:
It was fair enough. Certainly a step in the right direction.

x2, couldnt expect ideal judging but this was the best we could expect.

tkD · Sep 28, 2008

yep, fair enough imo, 1000000x fair for the 1st place, and not so good for 2nd -3rd - should have been Phil 2nd and maybe 3rd Jay

ddragaon · Sep 28, 2008

some good some bad
Phil and Wolf should have been 2nd and 3rd :350:

Beau · Sep 28, 2008

Toney should have been ahead of Wolf IMO and Heath should have taken the show...hes got the similar symmetrical proportioned physique that Dex has yet hes fuller and just looks bigger and better IMO he has no weak bodyparts

Sonelag · Sep 28, 2008

Something good something bad... If they are judging symmetry and conditioning over mass this year, then cutler was out of top 3 IMO. If they are judging all of the competitors with the same "rules", you can't put jay 2nd over Heath and let Dex win.

Pioneer · Sep 28, 2008

Dont know how the hell Silvo didnt make top 6.
Dont know how the hell Wolf beat Freeman.
Dont know how the hell Cutler beat Heath.

Other than other it was ok.

Flex · Sep 28, 2008

Pioneer said:
Dont know how the hell Silvo didnt make top 6.
Dont know how the hell Wolf beat Freeman.
Dont know how the hell Cutler beat Heath.

Other than other it was ok.

Exactly the way I feel.

:tiphat:

The Creator · Sep 28, 2008

I think it was good for the most part. I agree with dex winning but to be honest, I wouldnt have had a problem with Freeman winning the show :dunnodude:

Skeptic · Sep 28, 2008

im just glad cutler didnt win... this all just makes me excited for next year!!

afgan-ali · Sep 28, 2008

honestly but they neeeded too put jay cutler alot further down, but i understand its a respect thing soo they didnt other than that was pretty goood mayb a few swapped around, i thot they wer bit harsh on ronnie rokel but he looked realli good last nite

Was Tonight's Judging Fair?

Was the judging fair?

Yes, it was pretty much spot on.

No, it sucked balls.

Meh. Some good calls, some bad.

lifterdead

Mecca V.I.P.

Deathmaggot

Mecca V.I.P.

Flex

Mecca V.I.P.

lifterdead

Mecca V.I.P.

h0ke

Mecca V.I.P.

theweapon

Mecca V.I.P.

Pickle

Team Winklaar

Flex

Mecca V.I.P.

DriDDeRz

Mecca V.I.P.

Line

Chaos reigns.

MuscleMecca Crew

Mecca Staff

Rageking

Mecca V.I.P.

tkD

Administrator

ddragaon

Mecca V.I.P.

Beau

Mecca V.I.P.

Sonelag

Active member

Pioneer

Mecca V.I.P.

Flex

Mecca V.I.P.

The Creator

Mecca V.I.P.

Skeptic

I am god.

afgan-ali

Well-known member

Similar threads