Victor Martinez '07 vs Jay Cutler '09 - Mr Olympia

[tim290280]

Like Braaq I prefer Vic's physique.

You can't go past Jay though. Vic looks soft in comparison and I'm pretty sure that side by side Vic would be pwnd for mass. The side chest is evidence of that.

 

[Anabolicus]

Agreed, Jay takes it easily.

Edit: Vic's side chest looks awesome though.

 

[SerbMarko]

Victors quads are hideous. Cutler wins this one.

I agree.. his quads suck..

 

[Ironslave]

It comes to preference and I like Victor's physique much better (obviously) but I would have to agree this Jay actually deserves this win. One out of three deserved Jay! Good Job!

Jay deserved it in 06... Ronnie's asymmetry issues were pretty horrible, and that is a major aspect of bodybuilding.

 

[Braaq]

Jay deserved it in 06... Ronnie's asymmetry issues were pretty horrible, and that is a major aspect of bodybuilding.

I would say that about Jay then as well. He has asymmetry issues as well, Ronnie's were just more evident that year. But many had Vic ahead of Cutler that year, as far as I remember reading. Again, I guess it just comes down to preference because in 06 Jay was not nearly as hard as he was this year

 

[Ironslave]

I would say that about Jay then as well. He has asymmetry issues as well, Ronnie's were just more evident that year. But many had Vic ahead of Cutler that year, as far as I remember reading. Again, I guess it just comes down to preference because in 06 Jay was not nearly as hard as he was this year

I agree that this year's Jay was better than 06, but Jay did look great that year, it wasn't an overly huge difference. His 06 Olympia showing was probably his 3rd all time best, next to this year and 01. Vic didn't deserve to beat Jay then, no chance.

From 2006

http://www.musclemecca.com/showthre...e-pictures-2947.html?t=2947&highlight=morning

 

[Braaq]

True, he looked sick in those pics. Flattened out a bit during the contest though. I just think this one was no contest and no arguments that he was the dominant winner even compared to 06

 

[pakiman]

Aside from lighting difference the pics dont tell the difference in size of the the two... Jay of 2009 would have eaten Victor of 2007 for breakfast!

 

[L dimi]

jay for me , better quads , hamstrings , look very hard with muscle fulled