Career Comparison: Cutler Vs. Jackson

[RealDeal2099]

Going into this Mr. O, I was thinking about how if Dexter wins, he and Jay will both have two Olympia wins and three Arnold Classic wins. Also, both currently have 13 professional wins total. So, I'm wondering who you guys think will go down in history as the better bodybuilder.

I'm inclined to say Jay because he...

1) Had a tremendous breakout performance in 2001;
2) Unseated Ronnie in 2006;
3) Finished top two in seven consecutive Olympias (maybe more);
4) Won the "Most Muscular" award at each of his Arnold victories (this came up in another thread - Dex has not); and
5) Has established himself as a great ambassador for the sport through his work off the stage (e.g. appearing at muscle beach, publishing online training videos for his fans, etc.).

I also believe that Jay's best ever is better than Dexter's best, although I'll definately give Dex credit for 2008 - possibly the best single year of any pro career w/ five wins including the Arnold and Olympia. Thoughts?

 

[RealDeal2099]

BTW - I did a physique comparison here:

http://www.musclemecca.com/showthre...-vs-2006-mr-olympia-cutler-33780.html?t=33780

 

[weezy f baby]

jay cutler is a way better Mr O then dexter

 

[Flex]

Jay Cutler. Not even a question.

 

[weezy f baby]

cutler machines dexter on every pose... dexter comes in every year only 3-5 pounds heavier always comes with the same package he is not an exciting bodybuilder to watch.

look at ronnie and jay, every year bigger and more freaky package made every MR O exciting to watch......the only reason this 1 is exciting is cos phil heath last year compete at 227 lbs this year atleast 15 lbs heavier.

 

[PrinceVegeta]

Jay cutler no doubt. Jay in his prime beats dexter 100% of the time.

 

[tim290280]

I'm a big fan of Dex and have been for a long time.

But, and there always is a but, Jay so far is the better BBer. He has locked horns with Ronnie and beaten him (even if the last time was Ronnie lite and injured).

Dex would have to rack up a few more wins against some really tough competitors.

 

[mvsf1]

Jay all the way. First of all, he won more big trophies than Dex. End of the game.

 

[Storm]

Yes Jay is a better overall BB no doubt.

 

[SerbMarko]

Jay is way better for the sport.. i think Dexer is a "cock face, arrogant ass" physique wise, Jay in 2001 would be my choice if it were between just the2 of them.. Dex looks like a turtle..

 

[tkD]

So both have 13 wins each? didn't knew that. For the better "career" I'd say Jay for sure.

 

[RealDeal2099]

So both have 13 wins each?

So far. It'll be interesting to see if this changes on Saturday.