Cedric McMillan vs Roelly Winklaar

[COACH]

obviously is far away from Phil now

Rescued the best of your answer .. Great Words!
I'm a big fan of Cedric .. But Phil is from another planet my friend!

Competitive stats

• Height: 5 ft 9 in (175 cm)
• Competition weight: 245 pounds (111 kg)
• Off-Season weight: 270 pounds (120 kg)
• Arms: 22 inches (56 cm)
• Legs: 32 inches (81 cm)
• Calves: 20 inches (51 cm)
• Neck: 18.5 inches (47 cm)
• Waist: 29 inches (74 cm)
• Chest: 53 inches (130 cm)

Competitive history

• 2003 Northern Colorado State, Novice, Light-Heavyweight 1st and overall
• 2003 NPC Colorado State, Light-Heavyweight, 1st
• 2004 NPC Colorado State, Heavyweight, 1st and Overall
• 2005 NPC Junior Nationals, HeavyWeight, 1st and Overall
• 2005 NPC USA Championships, HeavyWeight, 1st and Overall
• 2006 Colorado Pro Championships, 1st
• 2006 New York Pro Championship, 1st
• 2007 Arnold Classic, 5th
• 2008 IFBB Iron Man, 1st
• 2008 Arnold Classic, 2nd
• 2008 Mr Olympia, 3rd
• 2009 Mr Olympia, 5th
• 2010 Arnold Classic, 2nd
• 2010 Mr Olympia, 2nd

 

[joligr]

Ronnie is from another planet my friend... Phil is a fantastastic BBer but not as dominant as you think he is. Maybe two or three Olympias, let's see Cedric, Evan, in 2014 for example... Even a Kay Green in his best shape could defeat Phil right now

 

[pakiman]

Everyone keeps frgetting its not POTENTIAL thats being compared... or at least thats my understanding!

We are comparing two athletes as they appeared on stage on particular dates. Truth be told Roelly NY 2010 would have kicked Cedric 2009 butt if they were on the same stage and held same condition as dipicted in these pics! Roelly appears to be way way way more polished and conditioned than Cedric!

For those who keep forgetting its conditions of two BBers at two shows is at comparison and just judge based on who has more potential... yes Cedric is many a folds better than Roelly.

But this particular comparison between these two... Roelly wins easily! IMHO