Gunter Schlierkamp (2005) vs. Toney Freeman (2006)

[Flex]

 

[Skeptic]

I gave it to gunter (waits for flaming) but i do have to say that his Ab&thigh pose is just horrible.

 

[Tunen]

the x-man takes it. Although Gunther is much sharper.

 

[Flex]

the x-man takes it. Although Gunther is much sharper.

Could you explain why you give it to x-man?

 

[nigster]

Gunter is more conditioned and has a slightly better upper body. Lower body goes to Toney.

I would give this to Gunter. It's a close call though.

 

[Daniel Andersson]

Front relaxed - Tony (Dont look as blocky as gunter does)
Front dubble biceps - Gunter (Very even IMO, I chosed gunter because he's sharper)
Front latspread - Gunter (I like Tony look more..but Gunter is sharper and takes it)
Side chest - Gunter - (Again, he is much sharper)
Rear dubble biceps - Tony (Outmassing Gunter)
Rear latspread - Tony (Outmassing Gunter)
Side triceps - Gunter (Sharper)
Abs & thigh - Gunter (Sharper)
Mostmuscular - Gunter (Sharper)

Tony would've had more if not all poses if he just was sharper.

Tony - 3
Gunter - 5

 

[PiC]

gunter`s back and thigh are a joke...

 

[Tonyk212000]

I never realized Gunters quads looked like that.

 

[Bodybuilderdk]

i mean look at xmans back double bi, his delts are redic, and gunters seems stringy, that abs and thigh is just DAMNNN....lol i give it to xman

 

[Samoan-Z]

Front relaxed - Gunter (Tonay has a pec bigger than the other, and too smooth)
Front dubble biceps - Tony looked sharper, but close.
Front latspread - Gunter is sharper and more symetrical, tony has pec misbalance and lat misbalance.
Side chest - Gunter, the definition if his delts and legs just stand out.
Rear dubble biceps - Gunter, he's drier more cut, almost to tony for hammy definition over Gunter.
Rear latspread - Gunter beats him in glutes cut, and lat balance.
Side triceps - Gunter. tony looks too soft in the thighs and arms.
Abs & thigh - I dunno Gunter for the cut, toney for the mass, gunter got huge waistline and toney got a smaller one...
Mostmuscular - Gunter is just sharper.

 

[PrinceVegeta]

X-man takes it!

 

[brendan]

they both lookgood.

 

[big_m]

toney has better overall physique imo

 

[Big_Guns_Lance]

I'd say the X-man! Gunter doesn't look very good there at all, shape wise, wide waist etc. Whereas Toney, well he's the X man lol. Gunters conditioning is better though. But man whats up with Gunters quads, they look weird.

 

[crossfirebmf]

How could anyone say Gunter? Well Gunter in 2005 for that matter. If it were pics of him from 2000 to 2002 he would've won for size and conditioning, but not in 2005. Neither of these are pics from either guy at their peak. If they were on stage standing side by side at the condition they were in these pics it would go to Toney.