Johnnie Jackson Vs Melvin Anthony

[Rageking]

melvin...

 

[Zigurd]

JoJ

 

[lifterdead]

I like JOJ's "style" of physique better, but honestly Melvin takes the cake.

 

[Braaq]

Melvin easily. Not that the burden of proof should rest on one side, per se, but I find it hard to believe that JOJ's inferior structure is winning this contest without any explanation as to why...unless all such posts were deleted.

They were deleted.... welcome back to the site by the way

 

[Line]

They were deleted.... welcome back to the site by the way

Thanks. Due to my mighty "powers" I could see that a great number of posts were deleted but felt as if there were too many to read through because of my present time constraints. However, Flex more or less hit the nail on the head with his assessment and I've yet to read what I feel is an adequate argument in favor of JOJ at this point.

 

[Braaq]

Thanks. Due to my mighty "powers" I could see that a great number of posts were deleted but felt as if there were too many to read through because of my present time constraints. However, Flex more or less hit the nail on the head with his assessment and I've yet to read what I feel is an adequate argument in favor of JOJ at this point.

I just argued for who won the rear double bicep shot, not the whole thing. I think my assessment of JOJ beating out Melvin's rear double bi was adequate (but that is up to you I suppose). However, overall Melvin has a better structure to JOJ's and as long as he is in shape he will beat JOJ.

 

[Paulie]

Melvin. He holds a better built structure than of JOJ's... (tighter waist...smaller hips) Conditioning is just about the same, except Melvin's legs are looking a quite a bit better.

 

[Beefcake]

I was lol'ing pretty hard at the original posts when I first read them. But honestly, I think Melvin wins this one overall. Neither athlete was in great shape, but Melvin will win this comparison just because his more dramatic v-taper makes him more aesthetic than JOJ is IMO.

 

[tkD]

ON topic: i voted for JOJ because i like his phisique more than Melvin, but both look good especially in back poses
OFF topic: how on earth JOJ has 36" quads?!?? http://www.muscletech.com/resources/athletes/johnniejackson/index.shtml ... sure is a HUGE mistake

 

[Minchinator]

I voted for Melvin, just like his look better, but each has qualities the other lacks, so it really is just personal preference on this one.

 

[ironheart]

JOJ in this battle. the only pose i'll give to Melvin is the front double bicep, the rest goes to JOJ.

 

[Big_Guns_Lance]

i voted for JOJ

 

[anaboliod]

this isn't melvin's best so in these pics i have to go JOJ although i'm a huge fan of melvin anthony's physique

 

[Hypocrisy86]

JOJ, pretty big..
also looked decently dry.

 

[Lionheart]

I voted JOJ cause he looks to better shape in there,but if they both would come in their 100% it would be an uppercut time..big uppercut.

 

[CombBoy]

JOJ. Has the most developed and powerful back from top to bottom thanks to deads for powerlifting. To me he also has a better physique than Melvin. They both need to figure out those small-ass effing calves of theirs!!

 

[brendan]

melvin.