Phil Heath 08 vs Ronnie Coleman 07

[mvsf1]

I've voted "Ronnie" before watching the pics. It's not fair, Ronnie wasn't at his worst since 95 in that pics.

Any Coleman from 98 to 2006 owns Phil at his best ever.

 

[mk47]

Stupid comparison....we all know Ronnie is on is way out, and at this stage Heath would beat Ronnie no question. But a prime Coleman eats Heath up for breakfast, not even close.

 

[Daniel Andersson]

Guys I dont really care about the old pics..he would win looking like he did before.
But the comparison was between the latest contest from Phil and Ronnie and nothing else The comparison will or will not prove that Phil could have been top 3 at this last mr.o

 

[mvsf1]

Guys I dont really care about the old pics..he would win looking like he did before.
But the comparison was between the lastest contest from Phil and Ronnie and nothing else The comparison will or will not prove that Phil could have been top 3 at this last mr.o

Then yeah, Phil whould have been Top 4 in the 2007 Olympia.

 

[Daniel Andersson]

It would have been a waste of time posting this if ronnie looked like he did before..

 

[Beau]

Stupid comparison....we all know Ronnie is on is way out, and at this stage Heath would beat Ronnie no question. But a prime Coleman eats Heath up for breakfast, not even close.

True but Heath hasnt come close to his prime...

 

[Iceman1981]

Are you serious? Ronnie would steam roll Phil anyday during Ronnie's prime. By the way, you're telling me you can't find any pics to use of Ronnie during his prime?

 

[Line]

So do you guys always just respond to the OP instead of actually reading through a thread before typing or are you just this dumb?

 

[Daniel Andersson]

Are you serious? Ronnie would steam roll Phil anyday during Ronnie's prime. By the way, you're telling me you can't find any pics to use of Ronnie during his prime?

That was still not the point !

 

[The Creator]

In the comparisons that we are given (assuming these were two random bodybuilders that we have never seen or heard of), Phil wins. Ronnie, in his prime, possessed the greatest physique that bodybuilding has ever seen and will ever see for a long time IMO.

 

[d.capodiferro]

phil heat is being so highlighted that i think that from today on i'll never support him.
stop appreciating him; let's see at least what happens at asc.
my hope is that ronnie will come back and kick his ass.
what if he win his 9th?
free from injury he can

 

[Line]

phil heat is being so highlighted that i think that from today on i'll never support him.
stop appreciating him; let's see at least what happens at asc.
my hope is that ronnie will come back and kick his ass.
what if he win his 9th?
free from injury he can

This is the most ridiculous post I've read today, and that's saying something.

 

[OH_Broker]

In the comparisons that we are given (assuming these were two random bodybuilders that we have never seen or heard of), Phil wins. Ronnie, in his prime, possessed the greatest physique that bodybuilding has ever seen and will ever see for a long time IMO.

X2

 

[Turkish1530]

I have not found any good pics of ronnie from 1998-2003..sure there are pics. but not like the pics posted

i can defiantly understand that...it's obviously not a very easy task to try and find pics that have them hitting the same shots all from the same year

 

[Turkish1530]

Guys I dont really care about the old pics..he would win looking like he did before.
But the comparison was between the latest contest from Phil and Ronnie and nothing else The comparison will or will not prove that Phil could have been top 3 at this last mr.o

don't get frustrated big brother...i would be....defiantly a good thread and i defiantly agree and understand taht u r just trying to use the most updated pics of the 2

 

[bangbang]

Not sure what's with the Phil Heath hype. All these comparisons and threads of Phil is a bit to much. Many are betting him above Victor Martinez, Melvin Anthony, and Dexter Jackson. Either way, he still looks good.

 

[nigster]

Judging by these pictures, Phil wins all the way. Side chest could go to Ronnie though. It's sad to see Ronnie in such a bad condition like that.

But...Phil in his Ironman condition VS Ronnie in his 2003 Mr. O condition (for example) would be a total meltdown.

 

[Napol3onator]

Why in the blue hell would you use the worst pictures of Ronnie ever taken???

Yea I know..thats like from 07 o isn't it..hes a poor washed up grandpa there, and he still beats phil..I like ronnies biceps better, yea buddy!

 

[Mygeeto]

phil heat is being so highlighted that i think that from today on i'll never support him.
stop appreciating him; let's see at least what happens at asc.
my hope is that ronnie will come back and kick his ass.
what if he win his 9th?
free from injury he can

thats what i was thinking until i seen the new pics of Phil from the Ironman, then i was pretty impressed to say the least. i give him credit where credit is due, but EVERYONE lines up to bend over for him. its sad.

i love how the comparision was between Ronnie's worst (appart from Mr. Olympia 2001 or 2002? cant remember which exactly), and Phil's greatest to date

Ronnie British GP 1999>>>>>>>>everything that ever lived and moved.

 

[Tonka]

The only flaw in Ronnie is midsection.