Heath vs Cutler (Mr.Olympia 2008 Preview)

[Braaq]

I voted on these photos and so I voted Phil, Phil should win because he embodies what bodybuilding should be about. I do realize though that a in shape Cutler will out mass and beat Phil. But in these pics, Jay looks like ass and if he lost to a Phil Heath like the one in the pics... I would throw my shoe at the judges

 

[atomic strenght]

if bodybuilding was about who's the biggest guy on stage then marcus ruhl should be mr o not jay.come on lets admit that jays physique last year wasnt good

 

[Arcane1129]

In these pics, Phil. He just has far better shape and his conditioning is so far ahead that it outweighs the mass difference... or at least it should. 06 Cutler would make a better comparison.

 

[Lionheart]

Resent pics Daniel?..so you couldnt use Mr.O final pics of Cutler?
Anyway..different stage and lights, but still Phil wins and Cutler looks worse than hes ever and i mean EVEEEER been in those pics.
I do think that Cutler will be at his best at this years Olympia and win

 

[Daniel Andersson]

Resent pics Daniel?..so you couldnt use Mr.O final pics of Cutler?
Anyway..different stage and lights, but still Phil wins and Cutler looks worse than hes ever and i mean EVEEEER been in those pics.
I do think that Cutler will be at his best at this years Olympia and win

I didn't want to spend 1h looking for pics..

 

[Lionheart]

I didn't want to spend 1h looking for pics..

Oh i understand

 

[Daniel Andersson]

 

[Joeb23]

Vic will be struggling...Wolf will be top 3, Phil aswell

Vic wins the O last year hands down and you are counting him out already. Let him heal up first and if he is 100% everyone on this board knows right now nobody can beat him.
Once Phil adds that much needed width up top which will be hard structurally speaking watchout...

 

[Daniel Andersson]

Vic wins the O last year hands down and you are counting him out already. Let him heal up first and if he is 100% everyone on this board knows right now nobody can beat him.
Once Phil adds that much needed width up top which will be hard structurally speaking watchout...

Right now everyone can beat Vic...he has a torn patella mate, and a injury like that can cause other tears up in the quad it self..I bet he still cant walk...And when he's recovered and can train legs again, he needs to build his strength up again...and thats not done over a night. Then the actuall tear might cause serious problem with his leg symmetri. And his legs was relatively bad before, with no sweep to the quads and "bad" seperation. This injury wont make it any better

But I hope he recovers 100%

 

[Iceman1981]

You should scale the pics to show a better comparison.

I would choose Phil over Cutler any day, but they will give Cutler the win because of his size.

 

[Daniel Andersson]

 

[Blond Bomber]

That's a good one. Thank you Daniel.

 

[FlexFan]

That's a good one. Thank you Daniel.

I don't think it's that good because Phil isn't that tall(he'll look a bit smaller and narrower)....anyway I prefer Phil but they'll give it to Jay because of the overall thickness(at a similar conditioning of course)...That's 40lbs+ at almost the same height...I don't think the judges can ignore that...

 

[Daniel Andersson]

I don't think it's that good because Phil isn't that tall(he'll look a bit smaller and narrower) The pic is just made smaller, the proportions are 100% accurat

....anyway I prefer Phil but they'll give it to Jay because of the overall thickness(at a similar conditioning of course)...That's 40lbs+ at almost the same height...I don't think the judges can ignore that...

 

[Ruhlforever]

Well guys, I can say I fell in love with Phil, Ruhlforever, member and lover of Markus and Ronnie Big Mass fell in love with Phil. But you can make a comparison yet, I mean is like comparing Britney and Paris, or Prince and Michael Jackson or Madonna vs JLO, or Beyone vs Rihanna or King Pelé vs Maradona, you know both have different styles, but I see in Phil lines and bellies and muscles I did not see in Ronnie, Jay, Flex, shit, this guy has one of the most impressive legs and without racism, please forget about it, for a black man guy he has one of the most beautiful calves, without a doubt with more maturity he will find the quads lines and divisions of Jay, I am seeing a vastus lateralis and biceps femoris with great Gracilis, a future ronnie coleman butt there and the best Brachialis that actually Jay wont never display. Phil is the man

 

[bb4life]

Jay would take it, but I prefer Phil's physique.

 

[Tonka]

Hard to say at this point.

 

[Flex]

Phil wins every one of those poses.

 

[templare1987]

Heath has a better structure than jay´s , his physique is better , only he have to improve is the side chest (chest)

 

[Joeb23]

Right now everyone can beat Vic...he has a torn patella mate, and a injury like that can cause other tears up in the quad it self..I bet he still cant walk...And when he's recovered and can train legs again, he needs to build his strength up again...and thats not done over a night. Then the actuall tear might cause serious problem with his leg symmetri. And his legs was relatively bad before, with no sweep to the quads and "bad" seperation. This injury wont make it any better

But I hope he recovers 100%

Yeah I understand and agree with you all the way. He may never be the same again and I hope and prey he can compete at the same if not higher level than he used to but right now it's just.. Also, I was just becoming quite confused with how it seems as though everyone has now jumped aboard the Phil Health train. Don't get me wrong I love the guy and he will be king one day I just feel a 100% Victor(like last years Mr. O) and a 100% Phil(Ironman) Victor wins all the way and it just appears since his injury everybody has lost sight of that.