High-Intensity Training vs. Volume Training for Bodybuilding

[BigArvin]

Bodybuilding enthusiasts often face the dilemma of choosing the most effective training method to achieve their fitness goals. Athletes have long debated the merits of high-intensity training and volume training. Some may succeed in the short, intense bursts of HIT, while others may prefer the gradual accumulation of workload in volume training.

This article will dissect these two training philosophies, highlighting their core principles, strengths, and limitations to help you choose the best path for your bodybuilding goals.


Starting 2024 doing some intense sh*t! For 31 days during the month of January, I will be uploading to YouTube every single day and make it a challenge to push myself. Consistency with various hero workouts, bodybuilding workouts, and cardio sessions.

Understanding the Basics​

High-Intensity Training (HIT)​

High-intensity training (HIT) is a workout approach that prioritizes short, intense bouts of exercise to maximize muscle engagement and push the body to its limits. It emphasizes quality over quantity, with shorter workouts but higher intensity. HIT workouts typically involve fewer exercises and sets to maintain focus on intensity.

This technique induces metabolic stress through intense, short bursts of activity, promoting the release of growth-promoting hormones. The focus on lifting heavier weights engages a higher percentage of muscle fibers, leading to increased strength and power.

Bodybuilders often incorporate squats, deadlifts, and bench presses due to their ability to target multiple muscle groups. Some also include isolation exercises strategically based on individual goals.

Volume Training​

Volume Training involves a higher volume of work, characterized by more sets and repetitions, to induce cumulative fatigue and promote muscle growth. It emphasizes the time-under-tension technique to stimulate hypertrophy. Volume training involves progressive loading over time.

The cumulative effect of volume training causes cellular swelling, promoting muscle growth through increased fluid retention. Higher repetitions and extended time under tension improve aerobic and anaerobic endurance.

It targets specific muscle groups with exercises like lateral raises, leg curls, and tricep kickbacks. Compound exercises like lunges, bent-over rows, and shoulder presses focusing on higher repetitions are also effective in volume training.

Benefits of Each Training Method​

HIT: Muscle Growth, Fat Loss, and Time Efficiency​

HIT's focus on maximal effort and intensity triggers a strong stimulus for muscle growth, especially by activating high-threshold motor units. Intense workouts can elevate the metabolic rate post-exercise, leading to increased calorie expenditure and potential fat loss. HIT's emphasis on intensity allows for shorter workout durations, making it appealing for individuals with busy schedules.

Volume training: Increased Muscle Hypertrophy and Endurance​

Volume training takes a more systematic approach. The increased volume in training creates metabolic stress, triggering hormonal responses and increased blood flow, leading to more significant muscle hypertrophy and sculpting. Frequent moderate-intensity training sessions improve cardiopulmonary function and muscular endurance, making you last longer during activities.

Anaerobic and Aerobic Advantages​

Regarding anaerobic and aerobic advantages, HIT primarily relies on anaerobic metabolism, utilizing stored energy without requiring oxygen. On the other hand, volume training often incorporates a mix of moderate-intensity exercises, utilizing both anaerobic and aerobic energy systems. This blend benefits cardiovascular health, improves oxygen utilization, and promotes overall fitness.

Drawbacks and Risks​

The intense nature of HIT may increase the risk of overtraining, leading to fatigue, decreased performance, and potential injury. The rapid and intense nature of HIT can temporarily spike heart rate and blood pressure, posing a potential risk for individuals with cardiovascular concerns.

Performing numerous sets and repetitions in volume training may increase the risk of overuse injuries, such as tendonitis or stress fractures. Prolonged workouts may stress joints more, primarily if proper form is not maintained throughout.

Practicing periodization can prevent chronic fatigue and optimize long-term progress. Gradually increasing the volume avoids sudden spikes in workload, which can lead to fatigue and overtraining.

Target Audience and Suitability​

Seasoned athletes who have mastered proper form and know their limits can wield HIT's intensity, reaping rapid strength gains and fat loss. It is also suitable for individuals with limited time for workouts seeking time-efficient training methods.

Beginners looking for a less intense introduction to weight training may benefit from volume training. It also suits individuals who enjoy longer, more traditional workout sessions. The moderate intensity of volume training is ideal for those who prefer a more sustained and controlled approach to weightlifting.

If the goal is muscle growth, intense sessions from HIT stimulate muscle growth efficiently. If the goal is to gain strength, volume training can provide this benefit through progressive overload and controlled repetitions. Understanding individual preferences, fitness levels, and specific goals is crucial for tailoring training programs.

Scientific Research and Evidence​

A meta-analysis by Schoenfeld et al. compared the effects of low-load, high-repetition training (similar to Volume Training) and high-load, low-repetition training (similar to HIT) on muscle growth. Both high-load and low-load training led to significant muscle growth, with no statistically significant difference. However, high-load training showed greater strength gains.

The study found that muscle protein synthesis elevated following low-load and high-load exercise, indicating that both methods can contribute to muscle hypertrophy.

A study from the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research investigated the effects of high-intensity resistance training (HIT) and high-volume resistance training on muscle strength and hypertrophy. In the results, HIT and high-volume training led to similar muscle strength and size increases, with no significant difference between the two groups.

Nutritional Considerations and Recovery​

Adequate protein intake is essential for muscle repair and growth, especially in HIT, where muscle fibers adapt to high-stress levels. It is also necessary in volume training to support the extended time under tension.

Carbohydrates provide the necessary energy for intense workouts in HIT. It also sustains the energy of bodybuilders in volume training to keep them working out for extended periods. Micronutrients support overall health and recovery in both workout techniques.

After intense HIT sessions:

1. Allow 48-72 hours for recovery before hitting the gym again.
2. For volume training, adjust rest days based on training intensity and muscle group engagement.
3. Aim for 7-8 hours of quality sleep each night to optimize muscle growth and hormone production.

Training Frequency and Workout Intensity​

HIT often involves fewer workouts per week due to the intense nature of the sessions. 2 to 4 sessions weekly allow for sufficient recovery between high-intensity workouts. Perceive the intensity level on a scale of 1 to 10, with 9-10 indicating near maximal effort.

Volume Training often involves more frequent workouts per week due to the lower intensity of each session. 4-6 sessions per week allow for a balance between workload and recovery. Focus on moderate to lighter weights with higher repetitions. Choose exercises and rep ranges (8-12, 12-15) that challenge you without reaching failure.

Adaptation, Progress, and Plateauing​

The progressive overload concept in HIT gradually increases the resistance or intensity. In volume training, gradually add more sets and increase repetitions to continue providing a stimulus for adaptation. Progressive overload is essential for stimulating muscle adaptation and preventing the body from adapting to the routine.

Rotate exercises or variations in HIT to prevent the body from adapting to specific movements to avoid plateaus. Introduce variations in volume training to target muscles from different angles. Regularly reassess and adjust training plans to align with evolving goals.

Real-life Examples and Case Studies​

A seasoned bodybuilder, Susan Carr adopted HIT to break through a strength plateau. According to her, "HIT revolutionized my training. Short, intense sessions helped me overcome stagnation. The results were phenomenal. My strength and muscle gains skyrocketed, and I appreciated the time efficiency." She built an impressive physique by advocating for low-volume, near-failure training and inspiring her fellow athletes.

Cesar Holden, an aspiring bodybuilder, embraced volume training for muscle hypertrophy. For Cesar, "Volume Training brought my physique to a new level. The extended time under tension and increased workload have sculpted my muscles like never before. It's not just about lifting heavy; it's about consistent effort and pushing beyond limits."

Conclusion​

The comparison between High-intensity training (HIT) and volume training sheds light on the diverse approaches available to bodybuilders in pursuit of their fitness goals. High-intensity training, emphasizing brief, intense workouts and maximal effort, has effectively promoted muscle growth, fat loss, and time efficiency. On the other hand, Volume training, characterized by a higher workload and extended time under tension, is recognized for enhancing muscle hypertrophy and endurance.

The key to success lies in understanding personal preferences, fitness goals, and the need for adaptability. By personalizing the approach, bodybuilders can navigate high-intensity and volume training concepts and principles to optimize their training routines, achieve sustained progress, and ultimately attain their desired physique and performance goals.