Phil Heath 08 vs Jay Cutler 01 (NR 2)

[The Creator]

Where have you gone jay...He is the clear winner here to me and its a shame that his physique has gone down hill from this shredded, symmetrical, mountain of mass.

 

[Ironslave]

jay wins but the conditioning is not better by him jsut look at his glutes not striated.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but arent those pics either a day out or day after the Olympia? If so, for Jay to look like that is amazing.

Jay wins these hands down, and I agree, such a shame he hasn't shown up like this since.

 

[Braaq]

If Jay looks like he does in the pics onstage it will go to Jay. He looks great in these pics, but he always looks good before shows and in the gym. He seems to screw up the day before or of the show and comes in flat or holding more water. Im not a fan of Jay, but he gets the nod from me in this comparisson.

jay wins but the conditioning is not better by him jsut look at his glutes not striated.

His glutes have never been striated, so I do not think that is relavent because he somehow is Mr. O.

 

[Zigurd]

Jay wins hands down...

I cannot believe Jay looked so amazing back in 01, just unbelievable.

 

[Daniel Andersson]

The pics are from the day after the show

 

[Zigurd]

The pics are from the day after the show

Thank you man !!!

 

[Flex]

This is the first comparison I've seen that I can say Phil loses.

 

[Pinhead]

Jay wins by miles. If Jay could keep that condition on the next competitions, he would very hard to beat.

 

[jdowden87]

jay all the way! he looked amazing in these pics

 

[Lisu]

Where have you gone jay...He is the clear winner here to me and its a shame that his physique has gone down hill from this shredded, symmetrical, mountain of mass.

x2

 

[PrinceVegeta]

Jay easy win

 

[mvsf1]

You must be joking.

Jay Cutler all the way.

 

[Turkish1530]

jayjay

 

[aroganttravis]

jay wins this easy.

 

[Pain]

I'd like to see a comparison between Jays first pro show and Phils first pro show.

 

[Daniel Andersson]

I'd like to see a comparison between Jays first pro show and Phils first pro show.

That will be really hard...is there even any pics from that show on Jay worth using?

 

[drexel1234]

heath wins everything but front double bi.

 

[cannonball33]

Jay wins. Heath has an awesome physique and props to him for all of his improvements, but he's narrow, in my opinion. And his side chest is odd.

 

[Ironslave]

heath wins everything but front double bi.

 

[MarkoB]

Jay easily. Damn he looked good, much better then these days...