Victor Martinez '07 vs Jay Cutler '09 - Mr Olympia

[tkD]

 

[tkD]

 

[mvsf1]

Man, Vic would look TINY next to 2009 Jay.

Jay Cutler all the way.

 

[sexnews]

Apples and oranges.

Vic 8-2

 

[ddragaon]

thanks tkD

I pick Victor

 

[Ironslave]

wow... i was expecting Jay to win this easily, by the pics I'm not so sure... tough call though without seeing them actually side to side in real life and seeing the difference.

 

[Ironslave]

Looking at these, Jay wins pretty clearly.

 

[Flex]

lol, you can't judge by those crappy videos James.

Jay in 2009 would win and deserve it.

 

[PrinceVegeta]

In prefer martinez, but cutler is just too big to be denied

 

[Ironslave]

lol, you can't judge by those crappy videos James.

Jay in 2009 would win and deserve it.

I agree Jay in 2009 would win, but the photos are what makes Vic look pretty close... but Jay wins pretty easily in the videos. I think the vids are pretty accurate with the pics being misleading.

 

[Flex]

I agree Jay in 2009 would win, but the photos are what makes Vic look pretty close... but Jay wins pretty easily in the videos. I think the vids are pretty accurate with the pics being misleading.

That's because the lighting at the prejudging this year sucked ass. The video of Jay was taken at the night show. But, the video of Vic doesn't do him justice, that video quality sucks ass compared to Jay's.

Jay had striations everywhere, his back was ripped to shreds. Pictures don't do that justice.

 

[tkD]

That's because the lighting at the prejudging this year sucked ass. The video of Jay was taken at the night show. But, the video of Vic doesn't do him justice, that video quality sucks ass compared to Jay's.

Jay had striations everywhere, his back was ripped to shreds. Pictures don't do that justice.

Yea I agree. It's not only the lighting in Jay's pics, but also the angle a bit, and of course the difference in scale, maybe Jay would look bigger in reality next to Victor, but from these pics you can't judge them properly.

 

[The Creator]

Victors quads are hideous. Cutler wins this one.

 

[Braaq]

It comes to preference and I like Victor's physique much better (obviously) but I would have to agree this Jay actually deserves this win. One out of three deserved Jay! Good Job!

 

[Napol3onator]

weird, but jay.

 

[dilatedmuscle]

The further i scrolled down, the closer i felt it got but jay wins without a doubt... I beleive a 09 dexter also beats an 07 victor... and maybe even an 09 branch

 

[mvsf1]

^^ Good point. It would be close between Dex08 or Dex09 vs Vic07.

 

[yair2210]

jay takes this one.

 

[SerbMarko]

I never thought I would ever say this.. but Jay wins..

 

[HeavyWeight_86]

Vic 07 was his all time best, but Jay eats him alive, look at the legs, he owns him in both mass and separation there, Vic's v shape in the upper body is great but Jay this year was teared to the bone and huge, not even close onestly.