• musclemecca bodybuilding forums does not sell or endorse any bodybuilding gear, products or supplements.
    Musclemecca has no affiliation with advertisers; they simply purchase advertising space here. If you have questions go to their site and ask them directly.
    Advertisers are responsible for the content in their forums.
    DO NOT SELL ILLEGAL PRODUCTS ON OUR FORUM

Classic vs Open Bodybuilding: Unveiling the Differences and Similarities

BigArvin

BigArvin

Well-known member
Author
Joined
Aug 7, 2023
Messages
159
Points
28
Bodybuilding has undergone substantial development, encompassing modifications in training techniques and aesthetics. It is a domain in which commitment, perseverance, and self-control merge to mold exceptional physical forms.

A notable transformation that has occurred is the transition from an emphasis on symmetry and proportion to one on mass and size. This shift is evident in the two main divisions of bodybuilding today: classic bodybuilding and open bodybuilding.

Classic vs open

Bodybuilding Divisions: Understanding the Basics​

Classic bodybuilding, alternatively referred to as "Men's Classic Physique," is an athletic discipline that honors the heyday of bodybuilding. It honors the human form's artistry, proportions, and aesthetic qualities. In this domain, participants aspire to achieve a sculpted, balanced physique.

Conversely, the most prestigious and earliest division of bodybuilding is Open Bodybuilding. The evaluation of Open Bodybuilders consists of their condition, mass, size, and symmetry. Open Bodybuilding has no weight restrictions so that competitors can attain any desired size.

Athletes must show unmatched dedication and perseverance in both classic and open Bodybuilding. However, there are vital differences regarding size and mass, weight restrictions, and posing techniques.

Historical Development​

In the mid-20th century, classic bodybuilding emerged as a reaction to the evolving dynamics of the sport. This category found its roots in the 1960s and '70s when people celebrated bodybuilding for its aesthetics and symmetry.

Classic Bodybuilding has maintained its unwavering depiction of the ideal human physique. As a result, the division implemented more stringent regulations regarding clothing and posing, thereby prioritizing the artistic dimension of the activity even more. Pioneers such as Frank Zane and Arnold Schwarzenegger exemplified the traditional physique of their era, which impacted the conception of this division.

Open Bodybuilding transformed in the twenty-first century. The desire to break previous size barriers led to the birth of this category. With the progression of training, nutrition, and supplementation, open bodybuilding observed an unparalleled increase in muscle mass. Athletes began pushing their physiques to the limits.

Ronnie Coleman and Jay Cutler exemplified the extreme size and muscularity that became synonymous with open bodybuilding. They served as a model for modern bodybuilding, motivating innumerable athletes to strive for enormous muscle mass and definition increases.

Key Characteristics of Each Division​

Bodybuilders who adhere to the classic bodybuilding style strive to attain a physique reminiscent of the golden age of bodybuilding. Typically, bodybuilders in this division have broader shoulders and smaller waists and concentrate on evenly developing all muscle groups.

Classic bodybuilding enforces strict weight limits and height-to-weight ratios, ensuring competitors do not attain excessive muscle mass. The classic bodybuilding division prevents competitors from gaining excessive muscle mass by enforcing stringent height-to-weight ratios and weight limits. These limitations encourage an aesthetic and physical balance.

Classic


On the other hand, Open Bodybuilders aim for the most enormous and most muscular physique possible. They aim to attain massive muscle size, remarkable muscular definition, and an awe-inspiring presence onstage. The focus here is on raw power and the ability to exhibit extreme muscle development. Competitors push the boundaries of size, often resulting in a significant increase in body weight.

Open

Training Approaches​

Both classic and open bodybuilders train very hard to develop their physiques. They typically train 5-6 days per week and focus on compound exercises that simultaneously work for multiple muscle groups.

Classic bodybuilders target muscle hypertrophy. They seek well-defined, proportionate muscles without excessive bulk. Bodybuilders under this division do conditioning to achieve a lean and defined physique with visible muscle separation and minimal body fat. They often use isolation exercises using dumbbells and barbells to help sculpt and define specific muscles.

Open Bodybuilders tend to focus on lower-volume and higher-intensity workouts. It helps them to achieve the maximum amount of muscle growth. These bodybuilders often use compound exercises to allow for more significant overall muscle development. They employ pyramid sets, drop sets, and forced reps to maximize muscle growth.
Due to the heavier weights involved, open bodybuilders use larger equipment such as leg press machines and squat racks. Lifting straps and belts help them to handle heavy weights safely, enabling them to lift more weight and stimulate muscle growth.

Nutritional Focus​

Bodybuilding requires adequate nutrition. Adequate nutrition supplies the necessary energy for rigorous physical activity. Proper nutrition is essential for its support as a fundamental component of gaining muscle. In addition, it is critical to regulate caloric consumption to sustain a slender physique.

Macronutrients are the nutrients that the body needs in large amounts. Bodybuilders must consume adequate protein to repair muscle tissue damaged during workouts and develop new muscles. Carbohydrates replenish muscle glycogen and serve as the body's primary energy source, supplying it with sustenance for exercise. Fat is essential for hormone production and cell function, which helps bodies recover from workouts and maintain a healthy body weight.

The period following a workout is when the body is most receptive to nutrients. Consuming a balanced meal with the right macronutrients within the anabolic window can optimize muscle recovery and growth.

Many bodybuilders also use supplements to complement their diets and meet specific nutritional needs. Protein powders provide a convenient way to meet daily protein requirements. Creatine supplements enhance strength and power during workouts, aiding in muscle growth. Vitamins and minerals rich in micronutrients can fill nutritional gaps, ensuring the body functions optimally.

Competition Criteria and Posing​

In classic bodybuilding, judges look at the competitor’s symmetry, proportion, flow, and condition. They focus on judging the V-taper–broad shoulders, a narrow waist, and well-defined muscle groups. Athletes should display well-defined muscles without sacrificing aesthetics.

Presentation, charisma, and posing routines are significant in this division. Bodybuilders not only flex their muscles but also grace, style, and overall stage presence.

Bodybuilders perform a set of mandatory poses, which include front double biceps, side chest, back double biceps, abdominal, and thighs. As for their final pose, they do a muscular pose to show the judges a complete view of the muscularity and proportion of their muscles.

In open bodybuilding, judges prioritize extreme muscle mass and size, looking for substantial muscle development. While size is critical, competitors should also exhibit remarkable muscle definition and separation, showcasing their muscularity. Vascularity is also often considered since it indicates low body fat and enhanced muscle definition.


Like classic bodybuilders, open bodybuilders emphasize upper body muscularity and proportion through the front double biceps pose. They also do the front lat spread, emphasizing the width of their back and the size of their lats and shoulders. The Most Muscular pose highlights overall muscularity, but it often means displaying more mass in the open category.

Culture and Community in Bodybuilding​

Classic and Open-division bodybuilders adhere to rigorous training regimens, dietary restrictions, and resolute self-control. The necessary mindset entails the capacity to establish objectives, diligently pursue them, and maintain consistency. Athletes must have faith in their capacity for development and transformation.

The bodybuilding community is very supportive of its members. Experienced athletes often guide newcomers, providing valuable insights and encouragement. This support helps individuals navigate the complexities of the sport. Additionally, The rise of online forums and social media has created a virtual community for bodybuilders.

Bodybuilding divisions are becoming more diverse. More and more bodybuilders from different ethnicities and backgrounds compete in these divisions. This diversity is a positive development for the sport of bodybuilding.

Regulatory Bodies and Rules​

The National Physique Committee (NPC) and the International Federation of BodyBuilding and Fitness (IFBB) are among the organizations that regulate bodybuilding. These organizations establish the rules and regulations for bodybuilding competitions.

Although standards and guidelines differ by division, competitors should adhere to certain principles. Before competing, organizations require bodybuilders to complete a physical examination. Competitors should wear a posing suit or bikini during the competition and perform a set of mandatory poses.

Every major bodybuilding organization has implemented anti-doping policies. The purpose of these policies is to prohibit the use of performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs) by bodybuilders. Organizations may select athletes for testing at any time during the competition period, ensuring compliance with anti-doping policies. Violating anti-doping policies can result in disqualification from competitions, stripping of titles, fines, and even bans from future events.

Professional Pathways in Bodybuilding​

Passion for bodybuilding is the foundation of a successful career. An intense passion for the sport will furnish the motivation and determination to achieve excellence. Educate yourself initially on the subject of training, nutrition, and recovery. Consider hiring a coach or trainer to help develop a structured plan tailored to your goals.

Start with regional and local competitions to acquire exposure and experience. These competitions offer an opportunity to hone one's abilities and evaluate one's level of competitiveness. Professional status grants access to elite competitions, including Mr. Olympia, IFBB Pro, and Arnold Classic. Participating in these competitions provides the chance to acquire sponsorships and rewards.

In addition to competing and sponsorships, bodybuilders can work as personal trainers, fitness models, or content creators who feature workouts, meal plans, or anything about the sport.

Case Studies/Profiles​

Chris Bumstead is a four-time Classic Physique Olympia champion. He is renowned for his extraordinary proportions and symmetry. His debut in Mr. Olympia turned heads, as he represented the epitome of classic aesthetics. Chris's physique features broad shoulders, a narrow waist, and perfectly sculpted muscles.

Chris bumstead


Big Ramy is a two-time Mr. Olympia champion. He is known for his incredible size and mass. His journey from Egypt to becoming a formidable force on the global bodybuilding stage is a story of dedication, perseverance, and incredible success. Ramy's physique features extreme muscle mass and remarkable vascularity. He showcases the pinnacle of muscle development in the open bodybuilding division.
Big ramy 2023 mr olympia


These athletes have made an enduring impact within bodybuilding and across the broader cultural context. They demonstrated the significance of commitment and exceptional performance to reach a professional career. Their success was not coincidental but resulted from their commitment and effort.

Conclusion​

Classic and open bodybuilding offer distinct avenues for enthusiasts seeking to transform their bodies into impressive works of art or powerful, muscular feats. Classic bodybuilding focuses on timeless aesthetics, proportion, and symmetry. This division involves symmetrical posing routines and emphasizes style and presentation on stage. Open bodybuilding emphasizes extreme muscle mass, size, and conditioning. It gives bodybuilders the pursuit of raw power and sheer muscle size.
The best division for you will depend on your individual goals and preferences. If you want to build a physique reminiscent of the Golden Era of bodybuilding, then classic bodybuilding is your proper division. Open bodybuilding may be right for you if you want to build the most muscular physique possible. Talk to a coach or mentor who can help you decide which division is proper for you.

Frequently Asked Questions​

Is there a weight limit in classic bodybuilding, and how does it differ from open bodybuilding?

Yes, there is a weight limit in classic bodybuilding. Athletes under the classic bodybuilding division must weigh under a certain amount, which varies depending on their height. For example, a competitor with a height of 5'8" to 5'9" has a weight limit of 180 lbs. While in open bodybuilding, bodybuilders can grow as large as they can.

Which bodybuilding style is more suitable for beginners, classic or open?

Typically, Classic Bodybuilding is more appropriate for beginners. It strongly emphasizes aesthetics, proportion, and symmetry, which can be more attainable and less intimidating for newcomers.

How do athletes in both divisions manage health, safety, and injury prevention?

Warming up before workouts and cooling down afterward help in injury prevention. Training programs are structured with periods of varying intensity to prevent overtraining and rhabdomyolysis. Athletes often use supplements like joint support formulas and multivitamins to address specific health needs.
 

Attachments

  • big ramy.jpg
    big ramy.jpg
    151.3 KB · Views: 4
Top