Cedric McMillan vs Roelly Winklaar

[tkD]

First thing, about the scaling of the pics. From what I know, and from their official sites, Cedric is 6'1" and Roelly somewhere @ 5'8", and from all the comparisons from the 2010 NY Pro, Roelly seems to be short next to Wolf, who's 5'11" or 5'11 and 1/2".

So based on this, and some other 6'1" bb'ers compared to 5'9" bb'ers (Gunter Schlierkamp vs Martinez or Cutler) I made these MK pics. More or less they could be pretty close to what they will look like on stage, height wise, so with this said and done, who do you think it wins?


"height sources for scaling"

Spoiler

McMillan 2009 Nationals
Winklaar 2010 NY Pro

 

[tkD]

 

[tkD]

Posing and presentation: Cedric > Roelly

I'm a fan of both, but for me Cedric wins, and I think he has a greater potential than Roelly.


BOOOOOOM!

 

[Skeptic]

Totally agree. Roelly is awesome, but Cedric has much better flow and presentation.

 

[mvsf1]

Roelly has bad luck, he just came into the mix and then suddenly the guy with best genetics since Ronnie Coleman appears...

1) Cedric takes it.
2) Lightning was WAY better in Roelly's show than in Cedric's.
3) Cedric's back could smoke 90% of pro BBs backs'.

 

[Natzo]

For me Roelly takes it but not for long..

Cedric already beats him in some shots and has better presentation.
At this moment Roelly for sure. In the future Cedric no doubt.

 

[yardharr]

We will definitely see these two battle it out on the same stage for years to come, the next generation of bodybuilders. Guys like Phil Heath and Kai Greene will continue to improve... there will be highly competitive shows!

 

[Line]

Line should make a Team McMillan

 

[tkD]

:io:

 

[dilatedmuscle]

Its like baby jesus gave cedric genetics that are specificaly designed for bodybuilding.

 

[nigster]

Cedric smokes him. End of thread.

 

[pakiman]

I know when Cedric is ready for the pro ranks and actually steps on the stage prepared for that it will definately be tough times for all not just Roelly... but based on these pics if those two stood toe to toe on stage... Roelly would have taken this one because of maturity his physique is presenting from almost all angles... well except for back shots but the rest Roelly takes this one IMHO!

 

[tkD]

Its like baby jesus gave cedric genetics that are specificaly designed for bodybuilding.

Holy shit dilated! Cedric is lurking on mecca from time to time haha!

check this:

dilatedmuscle:
"Its like baby jesus gave cedric genetics that are specificaly designed for bodybuilding."

i found this a few weeks ago... i thought that was pretty cool

Q and A with IFBB Pro Cedric McMillan post #723


Cedric if you see this please join musclemecca

 

[Skeptic]

That would be awesome if he joined MM!

 

[Salt]

Its like baby jesus gave cedric genetics that are specificaly designed for bodybuilding.

Jesus just forgot the calves...

 

[joligr]

Cedric has MrO potential for sure, even more than Phil. I just only see a week point, his biceps, no peak and no separation

 

[COACH]

Cedric has MrO potential for sure, even more than Phil. I just only see a week point, his biceps, no peak and separation

..You said .. Phil "The gift"?

 

[COACH]

Cedric hands down! ..4 other side
The density that is necessary for their long limbs is a lot!
Something that plays against him!

 

[COACH]

First thing, about the scaling of the pics. From what I know, and from their official sites, Cedric is 6'1" and Roelly somewhere @ 5'8", and from all the comparisons from the 2010 NY Pro, Roelly seems to be short next to Wolf, who's 5'11" or 5'11 and 1/2".

So based on this, and some other 6'1" bb'ers compared to 5'9" bb'ers (Gunter Schlierkamp vs Martinez or Cutler) I made these MK pics. More or less they could be pretty close to what they will look like on stage, height wise, so with this said and done, who do you think it wins?


"height sources for scaling"

Spoiler

McMillan 2009 Nationals
Winklaar 2010 NY Pro

Spoiler

...... Hide is Incredible!!

 

[joligr]

Yes, better flow and structure than Phil and 6,1". Cedric is just beginning his career, obviously is far away from Phil now but time to time... He reminds me a young Ronnie Coleman