Rank Mr. Olympia ( Jay Cutler)

[PrinceVegeta]

In his 2009 form, where would he rank in the list of Mr. Olympias?

1. Ronnie
2. Arnold
2. Lee Haney
3. Jay Cutler
4. Dorian Yates

 

[Big_Guns_Lance]

If each one of them would be in their prime then it would go like this...

1. Ronnie
2. Dorian
3. Jay
4. Haney
5. Arnold

Simple as that. Ive just obv used the guys in your post.

 

[sexnews]

Near the bottom with Dickerson, tried hard and eventually won.

 

[nigster]

This is hard, but here's mine:

1. Big Nasty
2. Haney
3. Arnold
4. Yates
5. Cutler

 

[Arcane1129]

Well, if we were using today's judging standards he would probably be 3rd-ish.

But if we're talking about how they were for their time, I'd have him behind a good number of winners.

 

[tkD]

This is hard, but here's mine:

1. Big Nasty
2. Haney
3. Arnold
4. Yates
5. Cutler

Nice list!

I'd have a minor change though:

1. Ronnie
2. Haney
3. Arnold
4. Cutler
5. Yates

 

[Big_Guns_Lance]

Nice list!

I'd have a minor change though:

1. Ronnie
2. Haney
3. Arnold
4. Cutler
5. Yates

LOL you sure don't like Yates one bit do you.

 

[cereal]

Minor change too:

1. Ronnie
2. Haney
3. Yates
4. Cutler
5. Arnold

 

[tkD]

LOL you sure don't like Yates one bit do you.

wut? I can't hear you!

 

[philosopher]

1. Ronnie
2. Arnold
3. Haney
4. Yates
5. Zane
6. Jay

 

[sexnews]

1. Ronnie
2. Arnold
3. Haney
4. Yates
5. Zane
6.Sergio
7. Samir
8. Franco
9. Dex
10. Jay
11. Dickerson

 

[Ironslave]

Today's standards:

Ronnie
Dorian
Jay
Haney
Dex

All time: (accounting the way they dominated in different eras)

Ronnie
Haney
Dorian
Arnold
Sergio

 

[mvsf1]

1. Ronnie
2. Dorian
3. Arnold
4. Jay.

 

[Line]

You can't possibly use today's judging standards...

 

[Pickle]

mmm its tough. he was good this year probably top 4

ronnie
arnold
haney
cutler
etc

 

[Line]

You can't possibly use today's judging standards...

To expand, I think if you were to rank the Mr. Olympia winners, I'd start with examining the validity of each win (which would incorporate the dominance in which the athlete won in relation to the caliber of competition they faced) and couple that with the amount of trophies they've actually captured. A somewhat crude approach, sure, but at least there's a basis for its approach.

Now if someone would like to actually assess the athletes based on this criteria I'd be happy, as I'm far too lazy a man to do it now.

 

[Flex]

To expand, I think if you were to rank the Mr. Olympia winners, I'd start with examining the validity of each win (which would incorporate the dominance in which the athlete won in relation to the caliber of competition they faced) and couple that with the amount of trophies they've actually captured. A somewhat crude approach, sure, but at least there's a basis for its approach.

Now if someone would like to actually assess the athletes based on this criteria I'd be happy, as I'm far too lazy a man to do it now.

That's what I was thinking. So...

1.) Lee Haney
2.) Ronnie Coleman
3.) Arnold Schwarzenegger
4.) Dorian Yates
5.) Jay Cutler


Judging based off of one physique...

1.) Ronnie Coleman
2.) Jay Cutler
3.) Dorian Yates
4.) Lee Haney
5.) Arnold Schwarzenegger

 

[miamiracing]

1. ronnie
2. cutler
3. haney
4. schwarzenegger
5. yates

 

[El Freako]

1. Everybody else
2. Jay

 

[yair2210]

ronnie
arnold
cutler
yates
haney

not by today's judging standards...