AlphaLifter
Musclemecca Staff
Author
- Joined
- Apr 5, 2026
- Messages
- 348
- Points
- 18
Nick Walker took his first Mr. Olympia in 2026, but IFBB Pro League VP Tyler Manion's pose-by-pose comparison in the Saturday finals actually saw Samson Dauda beat Walker.
In his Oct. 1st Olympia recap, Manion gave Dauda 5 of the 8 pose comparisons, Walker 3. Dauda was clearly up there in terms of fullness, proportions, and overall presentation, but Walker took the Sandow Trophy on the basis of his better all-around performance.
After the competition, Manion went through the required comparisons and explained how he assessed the top athletes. His analysis showed that the Walker/Dauda contest was very much a different affair when you got to the Saturday finals as opposed to the pre-judging.
Manion thought Walker had the edge over Derek Lunsford on Friday, winning five of the poses to three. Dauda was a very different proposition on Saturday and won five of the eight comparisons Manion had against Walker.
It's vital to separate Manion's individual pose assessment from the official Olympia results. His 5-3 was his assessment of the Saturday finals, not an alternative overall competition scorecard.
Front double biceps again, and Dauda was very impressive in terms of fullness, separation, and overall balance. His upper body development combined with his huge legs was very effective against Walker.
Dauda also got the vote in the front lat spread. Manion pointed to his shoulder width, chest thickness, the taper, and the relatively small midsection. Walker had very good conditioning, but Manion felt Dauda was the more well-rounded of the two in that position.
The side chest comparison also went to Dauda. His shoulder and arm development, combined with very good side leg density, helped him to match Walker's level of musculature.
Dauda then took the abdominals and thighs comparison, Manion again preferring his balance, proportions, and flow.
Finally, Dauda went for the favorite, most muscular pose. Manion was particularly struck by the improvement in Dauda's chest detail, his outer arms and shoulders compared to his appearance on Friday.
In the back double biceps, Manion went for Walker's rear taper and general presentation. He did point out that Walker still needed more back depth and thickness to really make the pose work.
Walker also won the back lat spread. His conditioning and lower body development were the things that set him apart, though Manion did point to further back detail as an area for improvement.
The side triceps was another strong position for Walker. Manion lauded his improved waistline control, abdominal thickness, and muscular detail. His ability to create a tighter-looking midsection and a very attractive taper was the difference in that position.
These three wins were a perfect illustration of why Walker was such a tough nut to crack, especially when his conditioning and presentation were on the money.
The official Men's Open scorecard confirmed the following results:
Source: Official 2026 IFBB Pro League Olympia scorecard. Lower scores = better placements.
Walker built his advantage during the prejudging, scoring 8 to Dauda's 15. Dauda did improve massively in the finals, but it was too late to overtake Walker on the basis of that deficit.
His consistency was the key to the win. Walker was all muscle, all the way through, in terms of his hardness, his conditioning, and his presentation. Dauda's improvement was all in the final.
The win also represented a very impressive comeback for Walker, who had finished 6th at the 2025 Mr. Olympia. He became the 20th Men's Open Mr. Olympia champion and took home the People's Champion award as well.
Manion felt Dauda wasn't quite as sharp as Walker and Lunsford on Friday in the comparisons. His Saturday effort was a marked improvement in terms of fullness, muscle, and general presentation.
That change in approach helped him to win five of the eight comparisons against Walker.
The result also shows that Dauda is still a real threat in the Men's Open. He's a big man with good proportions and a very muscular build, and when he's at his best, he's a tough nut to crack.
The race could get even more interesting at the 2027 Arnold Classic. Head judge Steve Weinberger indicated that Dauda could very well beat Walker should they meet again at the Arnold Classic in Columbus, Ohio on March 4–7, 2027.
For Walker, the challenge will be to keep the conditioning and the presentation that got him his first Sandow Trophy. For Dauda, it will be about improving his consistency between the prejudging and the finals, which could be the difference in another championship showdown.
Manion's breakdown ultimately highlighted a key point about the 2026 Mr. Olympia: winning more individual poses in a single comparison doesn't necessarily mean you win the competition. Dauda won five of the eight comparisons on Saturday, but Walker's superior performance over the two rounds saw him take the bodybuilding title.
In his Oct. 1st Olympia recap, Manion gave Dauda 5 of the 8 pose comparisons, Walker 3. Dauda was clearly up there in terms of fullness, proportions, and overall presentation, but Walker took the Sandow Trophy on the basis of his better all-around performance.
Tyler Manion Gives Samson Dauda the Edge Over Nick Walker in the 2026 Olympia Finals
The 2026 Mr. Olympia was in Las Vegas on September 26th, with Nick Walker, Samson Dauda, Derek Lunsford, and Andrew Jacked all in the mix in the Men's Open.After the competition, Manion went through the required comparisons and explained how he assessed the top athletes. His analysis showed that the Walker/Dauda contest was very much a different affair when you got to the Saturday finals as opposed to the pre-judging.
Manion thought Walker had the edge over Derek Lunsford on Friday, winning five of the poses to three. Dauda was a very different proposition on Saturday and won five of the eight comparisons Manion had against Walker.
It's vital to separate Manion's individual pose assessment from the official Olympia results. His 5-3 was his assessment of the Saturday finals, not an alternative overall competition scorecard.
How Samson Dauda Beat Nick Walker in Five of Eight Poses
Manion gave Dauda five comparisons: front double biceps, front lat spread, side chest, abdominals, and thighs, and he deemed him the most muscular.Front double biceps again, and Dauda was very impressive in terms of fullness, separation, and overall balance. His upper body development combined with his huge legs was very effective against Walker.
Dauda also got the vote in the front lat spread. Manion pointed to his shoulder width, chest thickness, the taper, and the relatively small midsection. Walker had very good conditioning, but Manion felt Dauda was the more well-rounded of the two in that position.
The side chest comparison also went to Dauda. His shoulder and arm development, combined with very good side leg density, helped him to match Walker's level of musculature.
Dauda then took the abdominals and thighs comparison, Manion again preferring his balance, proportions, and flow.
Finally, Dauda went for the favorite, most muscular pose. Manion was particularly struck by the improvement in Dauda's chest detail, his outer arms and shoulders compared to his appearance on Friday.
The Three Poses Nick Walker Won Against Samson Dauda
Although Dauda won the majority of their Saturday comparisons, Walker still had the advantage in three of the poses (back double biceps, back lat spread and side triceps).In the back double biceps, Manion went for Walker's rear taper and general presentation. He did point out that Walker still needed more back depth and thickness to really make the pose work.
Walker also won the back lat spread. His conditioning and lower body development were the things that set him apart, though Manion did point to further back detail as an area for improvement.
The side triceps was another strong position for Walker. Manion lauded his improved waistline control, abdominal thickness, and muscular detail. His ability to create a tighter-looking midsection and a very attractive taper was the difference in that position.
These three wins were a perfect illustration of why Walker was such a tough nut to crack, especially when his conditioning and presentation were on the money.
Why Nick Walker Still Won the 2026 Mr. Olympia
Even though they lost the Saturday pose comparison 5 to 3, Walker took the overall title as the Mr. Olympia was decided on the basis of the pre-judging and the finals.The official Men's Open scorecard confirmed the following results:
| Position | Competitor | Prejudging | Finals | Total |
| 1st | Nick Walker | 8 | 10 | 18 |
| 2nd | Samson Dauda | 15 | 5 | 20 |
| 3rd | Derek Lunsford | 9 | 15 | 24 |
| 4th | Andrew Jacked | 20 | 20 | 40 |
| 5th | Tonio Burton | 25 | 25 | 50 |
Walker built his advantage during the prejudging, scoring 8 to Dauda's 15. Dauda did improve massively in the finals, but it was too late to overtake Walker on the basis of that deficit.
His consistency was the key to the win. Walker was all muscle, all the way through, in terms of his hardness, his conditioning, and his presentation. Dauda's improvement was all in the final.
The win also represented a very impressive comeback for Walker, who had finished 6th at the 2025 Mr. Olympia. He became the 20th Men's Open Mr. Olympia champion and took home the People's Champion award as well.
Samson Dauda's Improved Finals Performance Changed the Comparison
One of the most interesting things about Manion's analysis was the sheer improvement Dauda made between the pre-judging and the finals.Manion felt Dauda wasn't quite as sharp as Walker and Lunsford on Friday in the comparisons. His Saturday effort was a marked improvement in terms of fullness, muscle, and general presentation.
That change in approach helped him to win five of the eight comparisons against Walker.
The result also shows that Dauda is still a real threat in the Men's Open. He's a big man with good proportions and a very muscular build, and when he's at his best, he's a tough nut to crack.
What Manion's Assessment Means for Walker and Dauda's Next Showdown
Manion's view of the contest is, of course, very interesting in terms of the Walker/dauda rivalry. Walker showed he could keep up the championship level of conditioning throughout the entire contest, whereas Dauda showed he could beat the current champion in the individual comparisons.The race could get even more interesting at the 2027 Arnold Classic. Head judge Steve Weinberger indicated that Dauda could very well beat Walker should they meet again at the Arnold Classic in Columbus, Ohio on March 4–7, 2027.
For Walker, the challenge will be to keep the conditioning and the presentation that got him his first Sandow Trophy. For Dauda, it will be about improving his consistency between the prejudging and the finals, which could be the difference in another championship showdown.
Manion's breakdown ultimately highlighted a key point about the 2026 Mr. Olympia: winning more individual poses in a single comparison doesn't necessarily mean you win the competition. Dauda won five of the eight comparisons on Saturday, but Walker's superior performance over the two rounds saw him take the bodybuilding title.








